Flagler College Athletics

All-Florida Sun Conference
1990	John Paul Treacy (Player of the Year)
1993	Jon Jonsson (first-team)
1993	Joe Trolan (first-team)
1993	Alan Okell (first-team)
1993	John Paul Treacy (first-team)
1993	Levent Ozcan (first-team)
1993	Paul McCaffrey (second-team)
1993	Mario Travlos (second-team)
1994	Jon Jonsson (FSC MVP, first-team)
1994	Brian Tennyson (first-team)
1994	Paul Tomaro (first-team)
1994	Mario Travlos (second-team)
1994	Levent Ozcan (second-team)
1995	Davis Haule (FSC MVP)
1995	Jon Jonsson (first-team)
1995	Jon Idle (first-team)
1995	Paul Tomaro (first-team)
1995	John Paul Treacy (first-team)
1995	Petur Bjarnason (second-team)
1995	Mario Travlos (second-team)
1995	Helgi Thordarson (second-team)
1996	Olafur Thor Gunnarson (first-team)
1996	Jon Thor Eyjolfsson (first-team)
1996	Paul Tomaro (first-team)
1996	Keith Caven (first-team)
1996	Steinbjorn Logasson (second-team)
1996	Chad Leton (second-team)
1997	Chad Leton (first-team)
1997	Olafur Thor Gunnarson (first-team)
1997	Jon Thor Eyjolfsson (first-team)
1997	Michael Lennon (second-team)
2000	Donny This (first-team)
2000	Jon Cantor (second-team)
2001	Donny This (first-team)
2001	Wayne Reilly (second-team)
2001	Steve Nyarady (second-team)

*Flagler College was a charter member of the Florida Sun Conference starting in 1990 (originally the Florida Intercollegiate Athletic Conference) and ended its affiliation after the spring season of 2005.

All-Independent Collegiate Athletic Association
2006	Sean Gormley (first-team)
2006	David Iafrate (second-team)
2006	Boris Kalff (second-team)
2006	Jordan Holtz (second-team)
2007	Sean Gormley (second-team)

All-Peach Belt Conference
2009	Johan Bergfeld (first-team at-large)
2009	Pol Berenguer (second-team midfielder)
2009	Kevin Partel (second-team defender)
2009	Conor Killeen (second-team at-large)
2009	Joseph Toby (Freshman of the Year)
2010	Johan Bergfeld (first-team)
2010	Joseph Toby (first-team)
2010	Matt Gilman (first-team)
2010	Will Frandsen (second-team)

Peach Belt Conference Coach of the Year
2009	John Lynch

District Co-Coach of the Year
1993	Bob Moullin

Florida Sun Conference Coach of the Year
1991	Bob Moullin
1994	Bob Moullin
1996	Bob Moullin